Mayan Risk Management: Ancient Lessons for Modern Portfolios

Finance Published: June 02, 2013
IEFDIAEEM

Unraveling the Hieroglyphics of Risk: A Modern Perspective on Ancient Wisdom

Imagine, if you will, a civilization that flourished around the same time as the Roman Empire, developing complex architecture, advanced mathematics, and an intricate writing system. The Mayans didn't just predict planetary movements; they also understood risk management in ways that resonate with investors today. Let's explore how Benjamin Whorf, a fire inspector turned linguist, connects these ancient hieroglyphics to modern portfolio risks.

The Enigma of Empty Cans

Benjamin Whorf worked for the Hartford Insurance Company, inspecting fires, and stumbled upon an intriguing observation: many fires were started by 'empty' gasoline cans. This paradox—something supposedly empty causing combustion—led him to hypothesize that language shapes thought. In essence, our perception of risk can be influenced by how we quantify it.

Risk Management in the Age of Mayan Empires

The Mayans understood risk management through their calendar system and astronomical knowledge. They knew that certain days were 'unlucky' due to celestial alignments. This is akin to today's investors avoiding certain sectors or assets based on historical trends or market sentiment. However, just as the Mayans couldn't control planetary movements, we can't eliminate risk entirely.

The Mathematics of Risk: From Mayan Calendars to Value at Risk

Mayan mathematicians used base 20 instead of our base 10. This reminds us that our choice of measurement systems—like daily closing prices versus intraday data—can significantly impact our perception of risk. Consider Value at Risk (VaR), a standard measure for quantifying portfolio risk. A small VaR number might lull investors into complacency, making the actual risk invisible—a modern 'empty gasoline can.'

Portfolio Risks: The Hieroglyphics Decoded

Let's examine how this relates to our sample portfolio consisting of C (Coca-Cola), IEF (iShares 7-10 Year Treasury Bond ETF), MS (Morgan Stanley), DIA (SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust), and EEM (iShares MSCI Emerging Markets ETF).

Risks: EEM has higher volatility than other assets, acting as our portfolio's 'empty gasoline can.' Its perceived emptiness—lower historical returns or increased risk—might lure investors into underestimating its actual risk contribution.

Opportunities: High volatility also means high potential rewards. Including EEM could enhance the portfolio's Sharpe ratio, balancing lower-volatility assets like C and IEF.

Practical Implementation: Deciphering Your Portfolio

To apply this knowledge, first, identify your 'empty gasoline cans.' Are there any assets with seemingly low risk but potentially high impact? Then:

1. Diversify: Balance high-risk/high-reward investments with lower-risk ones. 2. Monitor regularly: Risk isn't static. Regular portfolio reviews help catch changes in risk profiles. 3. Stress test: Use scenarios and simulations to understand how your portfolio might behave under stress.

Conclusion: Reading the Risk Hieroglyphics

Understanding risks is like deciphering Mayan hieroglyphics—it requires patience, context, and a willingness to challenge conventional wisdom. By embracing this perspective, investors can better navigate market uncertainties, turning perceived 'empty cans' into opportunities for growth.